Follow by Email

Thursday, June 28, 2018

Warning about Calvary Temple



The Calvary Temple Cult located in Sterling, VA, puts on four “free” sports and cheer camps each year over a two-week period. They tout themselves as “Christian” yet their leader, Star Robert Scott and other members are currently under an active three-plus year investigation by the Loudoun County Sheriff’s Office for allegations of CHILD SEXUAL ABUSE.
As recently as Monday, June 25, 2018, yet another comprehensive article was posted online by The Washington Post, further exposing and outlining the severe abuse and destruction to people, to children, and to families carried out, ordered or committed by Bob Scott, and far too many others in this place.
The article will be featured in The Washington Post Magazine, published on July 1, 2018, in the Washington Post Sunday newspaper. Please be sure to read the article whether it be online or in print.
We’ve been speaking out hoping to make the Washington DC Metro area, particularly the Sterling/Ashburn communities, aware of Calvary Temple. A simple Google search yields so much information regarding CT leadership and members’ destruction and abuse of entire family units.
Please, please, please do not attend these camps. While “free”, the cost to you and your children is astronomical. Please keep your family safe.

Warning about Calvary Temple



Mensaje de advertencia a las Comunidades de Sterling y las áreas circundantes 27 de junio de 2018

 

El Calvary Temple Cult ubicado en Sterling, VA, ofrece cuatro deportes “gratuitos” y campamentos de animado cada año durante un período de dos semanas. Se anuncian a sí mismos como “cristianos”, pero su líder, Star Robert Scott y otros miembros se encuentran actualmente bajo una investigación activa de más de tres años por parte de la Oficina del Sheriff del condado de Loudoun por denuncias de ABUSO SEXUAL DE NIÑOS.
Recientemente, el lunes 25 de junio de 2018, otro artículo completo fue publicado en línea por The Washington Post, exponiendo y delineando aún más el severo abuso y destrucción a personas, niños y familias llevadas a cabo, ordenadas o cometidas por Bob Scott, y demasiados otros en este lugar.
El artículo será presentado en The Washington Post Magazine, publicado el 1 de julio de 2018, en el periódico The Washington Post Sunday. Por favor, asegúrese de leer el artículo ya sea en línea o impreso.
Hemos estado hablando con la esperanza de que el área metropolitana de Washington DC, particularmente las comunidades Sterling / Ashburn, conozcan el Templo Calvary. Una simple búsqueda en Google arroja mucha información sobre el liderazgo de CT y la destrucción y abuso de miembros de unidades familiares enteras.
Por favor, por favor, no asistan a estos campamentos. Mientras que es “gratis”, el costo para usted y sus hijos es astronómico. Por favor, mantenga segura a su familia.

Monday, June 25, 2018

Update by the Washington Post





In March of 2015, the Loudoun Times Mirror published the first in a series of articles concerning Calvary Temple of Sterling, VA. In addition, local tv stations, blogs from former members of CT, and on-line news organizations have contributed to the coverage.

Today the Washington Post printed the following article on their on-line edition. This Sunday, July 1, 2018,  it will be printed in the Washington Post magazine. 

Sunday, June 17, 2018

Father's Day

It has been many years since I have heard Star Scott's teachings concerning the family and specifically fathers, but I suspect they have not changed throughout the years. He taught that fathers were to reinforce the teaching of the pastor rather than hear from God for the leading of their own families. He spoke of families having "family time" at church - "what better place?" he would ask. He emphasized that the family is secondary to the meeting of the church. In the midst of these teachings, he communicated the strong message that to stay home with your family on a Friday night for "family time" (he would say "family time" rather mockingly) was akin to indulging one's flesh. Scripture says otherwise and therefore I offer the following from the Source of all truth:


For I have chosen him, that he may command his children and his household after him to keep the way of the LORD by doing righteousness and justice, so that the LORD may bring to Abraham what he has promised him. Genesis 18:19

These words that I am giving you today are to be in your heart. Repeat them to your children. Talk about them when you sit in your house and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up. Deuteronomy 6:6-7.

But as for me and my house, we will serve the LORD. Joshua 24:15

Listen, my son, to your father’s instruction, and don’t reject your mother’s teaching. Proverbs 1:8.

Train up a child in the way he should go; even when he is old he will not depart from it. Proverbs 22:6

And fathers, don’t stir up anger in your children, but bring them up in the training and instruction of the Lord. Ephesians 6:4.

But if any provide not for his own, and specially for those of his own house, he hath denied the faith, and is worse than an infidel. 1 Timothy 5:8

…clearly recalling your sincere faith that first lived in your grandmother Lois, then in your mother Eunice, and that I am convinced is in you also. 2 Timothy 1:5.

But if any widow has children or grandchildren, they should learn to practice their religion toward their own family first and to repay their parents, for this pleases God. 1 Timothy 5:4.



From Pastors:


If therefore our houses be houses of the Lord, we shall for that reason love home, reckoning our daily devotion the sweetest of our daily delights; and our family-worship the most valuable of our family-comforts… A church in the house will be a good legacy, nay, it will be a good inheritance, to be left to your children after you.   Matthew Henry, Clergyman

A family is a place where principles are hammered and honed on the anvil of everyday living.  Chuck Swindoll, Pastor

In the family, life is brought not only to our doorstep, but into our kitchens, bedrooms, and dens. In the family, life is happening all around us, and it begs to be questioned, evaluated, interpreted, and discussed. There is no more consistent, pregnant, dynamic forum for instruction about life than the family, because that is exactly what God designed the family to be, a learning community.  Paul David Trip, Pastor

“The family should be a closely knit group. The home should be a self-contained shelter of security; a kind of school where life’s basic lessons are taught; and a kind of church where God is honored; a place where wholesome recreation and simple pleasures are enjoyed.”  Billy Graham

We do not develop habits of genuine love automatically. We learn by watching effective role models – most specifically by observing how our parents express love for each other day in and day out.  Josh McDowell

Let no Christian parents fall into the delusion that Sunday School is intended to ease them of their personal duties. The first and most natural condition of things is for Christian parents to train up their own children in the nurture and admonition of the Lord.  Charles Spurgeon

You want to mess up the minds of your children? Here’s how – guaranteed! Rear them in a legalistic, tight context of external religion, where performance is more important than reality.  Chuck Swindoll



Having sat under Star Scott's teaching for many years, I can well imagine his rebuttal to the concept of "family time". During the years we attended Calvary, he frequently quoted this scripture:

Not giving up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another--and even more as you see the Day approaching. Hebrews 10:25


Mr Scott frequently used this scripture to justify the endless meetings we were required to attend. "and even more.......amen?!!!" he would emphasize. So my question is - why have the leaders and members of Calvary Temple put a limit on this scripture? If the meaning of this scripture is to encourage believers to meet together increasingly more and more, then why is CT only meeting 5 or 6 evenings a week? Why not every morning and every evening? Why not stay home from work? Or why not live in one place so that they can fulfill the "even more" portion of this scripture? Why has the leadership of Calvary Temple placed a limitation on "even more"?


According to Bible scholars:


There was a regular meeting of the church on the first day of the week. The believers were admonished to regularly attend this meeting of the believers - to be faithful to this church-wide meeting - and to remain faithful - and even more as we see the Day approaching. It did not mean to have more and more meetings - it meant to be faithful to the meeting of the church on the first day of the week.

In addition to the regular meeting of the church, there were other meetings for specific purposes. The church met to pray for Peter when he was arrested by Herod. Paul taught in the school of Tyrannous at Ephesus for almost 2 years. Many believers met in their homes for fellowship and breaking of bread. But these meetings were for specific purposes, or for a limited time, or attended by some and not others. The church - meaning the followers of Jesus Christ - was led by the Holy Spirit to carry out His work on the earth and therefore, met as God led them. To be equipped for that work, they met weekly. It is this weekly meeting that they were encouraged to attend "even more as we see the Day approaching".

If the church is to meet every night of the week as well as "even more", culminating in a constant attendance of "church", then the above scriptures concerning fathers and their families cannot be carried out. God set us into families for a reason. It is the place where fathers and mothers, being equipped by God, carry out the biblical teachings necessary to train the next generation. It is the parent's God-ordained responsibility to teach their children "when you sit in your house and when you walk along the road, when you lie down and when you get up." The meeting of the church on the first day of the week is the time when the five fold ministry equips the saints to do this work in their families as well as their own Jerusalem.

Fathers in Calvary Temple are not able to fulfill the scriptures concerning their own families. There is no time for them to bring their own children up in the nurture and the admonition of the Lord when they are continually handing them over to others to do the work. And there is no example being set of a father seeking God for the direction of his own life as well as that of his family. His children are not learning to hear from God, they are learning to hear from the pastor. If we as believers are being equipped to do the work of the ministry, then we need time to DO it, beginning in our own homes.


Fathers, on this day, please take back your God-given right and responsibility to lead your own family.


Happy Father's Day

Sunday, May 20, 2018

Calvary Temple - No, You Are Not Free



Recently the pastor of the church I attend taught from Isaiah 6. Toward the end of the teaching, he referenced verse 8.

Then I heard the voice of the Lord saying, "Whom shall I send? And who will go for us?" And I said, "Here am I. Send me!"

The pastor spoke to those who might feel a call on their lives to enter full time ministry. Acknowledging that it can be a struggle to make this life changing decision, he asked them to come forward that he might pray for them. His comments and prayer encouraged each man and woman to seek God for direction. He said "This is your decision, between you and God". "He will speak to you". "I cannot give you the answer, only God can." "Lord, as you call these folks....begin to clarify things for them". "However long it might be, give them patience to wait on You." As two of my family members went forward, I joined with the pastor and the rest of the congregation praying for direction and confirmation.

I have continued to think about Isaiah, a man who desired to be used of God. Isaiah stood before the Lord and heard His voice speaking to him. And he answered- "Here am I. Send me!" The Lord has been calling men into ministries for thousands of years. He called Abraham out of Ur; Moses out of Egypt; and Aaron from the Levites. God called Paul, the disciples, and others into ministry.

So now some thoughts concerning Calvary Temple members.

It has been interesting that many in CT are quick to let us know that they are free to make their own decisions. They assure us that the pastors or deacons do not control their lives, they are free to choose their spouses, vocations, ministries, friends, etc. But I would assert that Calvary Temple members are not free. 

How many of you have felt a call into ministry but were told by leadership that they did not agree? And not only that they did not agree but you did not hear from God. Many have had to leave CT in order to fulfill the call of God on their lives. You are not free to make your own decisions, you are not free to stand before God and hear His voice leading and guiding you.

(The following statements of Star Scott are from Supernatural Yet Orderly September 26, 2005)

"We had an incident here recently when someone came and said, 'I feel that the Lord might be leading me to do this.' Unless it was confirmed of us, it wasn't God."

So in other words, Star Scott will supposedly tell you if you heard from God. Or not. Why not skip to the end and just do whatever they tell you? (Well, I guess that's exactly what you already do.) If they don't agree with you, you are apparently the one who is wrong.

"It's important to understand that God emphasizes to a far greater degree the principles of spiritual leadership, of the multitude of counsel, of spiritual gifts, and give them far more credibility than your individual impulses and intuitive notions."

Why does Star Scott refer to church members hearing the voice of God as "individual impulses and intuitive notions"?  Doesn't Scott's choice of vocabulary minimize the mighty and awesome truth that we are guided by the in-dwelt Holy Spirit? And yet he has "far more credibility" than you do. In fact, God emphasizes to a far greater degree the inner voice of the Holy Spirit, given to us by God Himself, to be able to hear and walk in His will.

"We're down here fleshing out at whatever it is that we might be doing. We're on mall patrol shopping, maxing out our fourth credit card, stopping at this ice cream place and this candy store, and then we get a "word from the Lord." It's probably a reaction to all that chocolate and ice cream! So many of us are so confident in what we hear--that intuitive voice, "I believe God just told me." How can you hear Him in the midst of all this noise of playtime?"

Why does Star Scott portray those believing they should go into ministry as ones who are fleshing out at the mall? Most likely the ones maxing out their credit card and eating their way through candy and ice cream buffets are probably not thinking they want to go to India to share the gospel.

Scott speaks as though the church members are living a life of playtime while he has a direct line to God for the direction of your life. If that's what he thinks about the members of CT, it's no wonder he "lords it over" you. He has no respect for your individual relationship with God and does not believe you are capable of hearing from Him.

So, if you approach leadership and express a desire to completely turn your life upside down, move to a third world country, give up friends and family back home, live in austere conditions, and quit well paying jobs, how will you be thought of? Is Star Scott going to accuse of you of having a reaction to too much pizza the night before? Of fleshing out and wanting to have party time? Are you going to be told that the voice you hear is just an impulse? Just a notion? And that you are a fleshpot waiting to happen?

Now compare the above statements by Star Scott with the opening remarks of the pastor quoted at the opening of this post. His encouragement to the believer is to trust the voice and leading of God, to have patience as He sets His plans in motion, and to know He will order your steps. He knows and understands that if you seek God, you will find Him. And if you make a mistake, God will set you back on the right path. He respects your individual relationship with God. In other words, he trusts God and encourages you to do the same.

Is there a time to seek counsel from other Christians? Of course! There is safety in a multitude of counselors. Seeking counsel is part of the wisdom God imparts to His children. 

Proverbs 1:5 let the wise listen and add to their learning, and let the discerning get guidance.

Note that we are to listen and add to our learning. It is part of the process of hearing and confirming God's voice to us. Our confidence comes from our relationship with Jesus, the One who came to dwell within our hearts. We cannot defer to pastors for decisions about our life's direction. One day we will stand before God; we cannot say we didn't follow His will for our lives because our pastor said no.

The word of God is our final authority, not the word of Star Scott. 

Psalm 119:105 Your word is a lamp to my feet and a light to my path.

The leading of the Holy Spirit is our promise from God:

John 10: 3-5 I hear Jesus’ voice and He calls me by name and leads me out. Jesus goes before me and I follow him, for I know his voice. I will by no means follow a stranger. 

Isaiah 30: 21 Whether you turn to the right or to the left, your ears will hear a voice behind you, saying, “This is the way; walk in it.”

Romans 8:14 I am led by the Spirit of God for I am a son of God. 

Sadly, Star Scott has taught for years that you are incapable of hearing from God for your own life.  And at the very least, he can hear much better than you. For your life. Which means he is in charge of your life. You are not making your own decisions, he is. 

Star Scott should take heed to the following scripture:  

Mark 10:42-43 Jesus called them together and said, “You know that those who are regarded as rulers of the Gentiles lord it over them, and their high officials exercise authority over them. Not so with you. Instead, whoever wants to become great among you must be your servant.


I don't often post videos, but this song beautifully expresses our freedom in Jesus.

Tuesday, April 24, 2018

"We Protect our Children" - UPDATE AND CONFIRMATION OF ABUSE BY ONE VICTIM

In a recent message at Calvary Temple of Sterling Virginia, Star R Scott spoke the following:

"Dear God, the young people's lives that are being destroyed today. I cannot believe how Christians are putting their kids out in the public arena and having them defiled through our education systems. ..You know all of the uproar today of kids being afraid to go to school... Our children are here, we keep 'em safe. Praise God. I pity the dude that tries to come here and shoot somebody."

And so, in light of this bold declaration....

"Our children are here, we keep 'em safe" 

I have a few questions for Calvary Temple leadership and members.

  • What about those that have left Calvary Temple because of childhood sexual, physical, psychological and emotional abuse?
  • What about those currently IN YOUR CONGREGATION who say they have been abused?
  • And adults currently IN YOUR CONGREGATION who have been accused of child sexual and physical abuse?
  • What about the ongoing investigation of Calvary Temple concerning these allegations?
  • What do you think of the fact that the still active investigation by the Loudoun County Sheriff's Office and the State Police has been turned over to the Virginia Commonwealth Attorney?
There are children outside of Calvary Temple and amongst you that do not feel safe and protected. On the contrary, they feel used and abused, vulnerable, and decidedly UNPROTECTED AND UNSAFE. 
  • And finally, are you troubled by the fact that Star Scott has recently told you he has criminal charges that he had expunged from his record?  and that in the context of this message, he made it clear that you are not to ask what it was that he had expunged? 
note - you must pay to have your record expunged, and usually you must hire a lawyer to handle the details. 


John 3:19 This is the judgment, that the Light has come into the world, and men loved the darkness rather than the Light, for their deeds were evil.

Isaiah 29:15 Woe to those who deeply hide their plans from the LORD, And whose deeds are done in a dark place, And they say, "Who sees us?" or "Who knows us?

Joshua 7:19 Then Joshua said to Achan, "My son, I implore you, give glory to the LORD, the God of Israel, and give praise to Him; and tell me now what you have done. Do not hide it from me."

Jeremiah 16:17 For My eyes are on all their ways; they are not hidden from My face, nor is their iniquity concealed from My eyes.

UPDATE:  

From the Washington Post Article dated July 1, 2018 


"The email alleged that Scott Sr. had molested his two young nieces for years, starting when he was a youth pastor at Greenfield Assembly of God Church in Bakersfield, Calif., and continuing into his Herndon days in the early ’70s. “THEY WERE JUST INNOCENT CHILDREN AND YOU ABUSED YOUR POWER AND AUTHORITY,” the email said. According to Scott Jr.’s former wife, the couple also reported the allegations to the Herndon Police Department. (Scott Jr. did not respond to messages sent through intermediaries seeking comment.) In a partially redacted copy of a 2008 police report that I obtained under a Freedom of Information Act request, one of the nieces, Lori Upshaw, confirmed the story. The report said that Virginia prosecutors declined to pursue the case and suggested the victim press charges in California. But she ultimately decided not to do so. Reached by phone, Upshaw, who was a Greenfield congregant, said her uncle began molesting her regularly when she was 11 and continued until she was 15."

Sunday, March 25, 2018

Another Twisted Scripture Update

Feeling fairly certain that Star Scott reads the blogs about Calvary Temple, I wondered how he would refute the previous post. Entitled Another Twisted Scripture by Star Scott, Scott erroneously taught that scripture commands us to meet at the church daily. It has come to my attention that he backtracked rather quickly.

And here is how Scott did it: one of his associates, during a panel discussion, gave Scott an out by referring to daily church attendance as "our tradition".  No longer is it a biblical command as he had previously taught, it is now just a "tradition".

This opens the door to referring to other unscriptural commands as traditions.

And so Calvary Temple members are now obligated to follow whatever directives the pastors come up with. Could be anything, even though it may not have any clear biblical mandate. Anything like:
  • no dating
  • ridiculously short engagements
  • only marrying people within Calvary Temple
  • marrying those you don't love because you have no other choices
  • encouraging divorce for "spiritual" adultery
  • using money intended for outreach or building programs to buy cars for the pastors
  • no oversight of church finances
  • shunning those who have left Calvary Temple
  • destroying families
  • never leaving to attend another church without pastor's permission
  • putting a mother of 5 children in a hotel for more than 3 months
  • remaining separate from other local churches because other churches are just not good enough
  • putting children out on the street because the children have doubts about their beliefs
I am sure members of Calvary Temple can think of lots of "traditions" that they have to hold to even though they are not convinced they are biblical.

Mark 7:13 "Thus you nullify the word of God by your tradition that you have handed down. And you do many things like that."





Thursday, February 15, 2018

Another Twisted Scripture by Star Scott


Using the following verse from The Book of Acts, Star Scott is teaching that it is mandated to meet daily at Calvary Temple:

Acts 2:45 "With one accord they continued to meet daily in the temple courts..."

As quoted by Star Scott: "They met daily in the temple".

Conclusion by Star Scott:  We are to be here at Calvary Temple everyday, and if you are not, you are selfish, self indulgent, sinning willfully, with no sacrifice remaining for your sins. 

The verse in context: 

Acts 2: 44-46  All the believers were together and had everything in common. Selling their possessions and goods, they shared with anyone who was in need. With one accord they continued to meet daily in the temple courts and to break bread from house to house, sharing their meals with gladness and sincerity of heart...

From Star Scott -  January 17, 2018 Wed pm.

"We were talking in the deacons meeting, and I will actually make reference to some of these things, but we were talking about the lack of attendance on Friday night family night, and people were coming up with a number of reasons as to why this has been slacking off. And we might speak toward some of these things. As we look at all of them, however, being unacceptable, because the word of God mandates that we meet daily. ....one of the things people said to justify... well you know during basketball season away games come there's not that many people up there.....so why bother to go? Can we remind ourselves that where 2 or 3 are gathered together in His name He is there in His presence? .....and later Scott says"Jesus is worth coming up here to visit, amen? It's about Him, not the two or three."

Please note that Star Scott did not include Acts 2:44 or 2:46. He "cherry picked" the middle verse, vs 45:  "They... met daily in the temple." Does this verse support the requirement for the current day church to meet daily? Why did he omit the verses prior to and after "they ...met daily in the temple"?

Quoting just verse 45 should raise some questions. If scripture does in fact teach that we should be meeting daily in the "temple", then we should also consider verses 44 and 46. If we truly are required by scripture to "attend Calvary Temple daily", then the requirements of selling all we have, sharing with anyone who has need and meeting in our homes daily must also be established.

Considering the full context of this verse, and its application by Star Scott, the following questions should be asked:
  1. Should we sell everything and have all in common?
  2. Should we meet daily in the temple courts? 
  3. Who actually met daily in the temple courts?
  4. Is the temple (or the temple courts) of Jerusalem synonymous with "the local church"?
  5. What is the meaning of "church"? 
  6. Should we meet daily in homes and share our meals?
  7. Are we the "church" when we meet in our homes?
  8. Is Jesus in the "temple" (Calvary Temple building) or in the "church" (believers).
  9. What is the difference between historical accounts in scripture and instructions to the church?

1. Should we sell everything and have all in common?  The selling of property was not obligatory. The examples of Barnabas and Ananias demonstrate the voluntary nature of this method of benevolence. Peter told Ananias, “While it remained unsold, did it not remain your own? And after it was sold, was it not at your disposal?” (Acts 5:4). It is apparent that not all Christians sold their property, for the disciples were later meeting in the house of Mary, Mark’s mother, in Acts 12:12.  Though it is recorded that the early church in Jerusalem held things in common, it is not a mandate for us to do the same. 
2. Should we meet daily in the temple?  The only example of Christians meeting daily in the temple are of the new Jewish believers who continued their custom of going to the temple. (They still considered themselves Jews.) There they shared their new found faith. In the temple courts, and other public places, they preached to their fellow Jews, but they met in their homes to practice their new Christian faith. Continuing to go to the temple daily was their opportunity for evangelism. They later established Sunday as the day the church met corporately. They also met at other times and locations, depending on circumstances. Slowly, Christians did not see themselves as Jews anymore, but as a separate religion, so they stopped going regularly to synagogues.
3. Who actually met daily in the Temple?  Only the Jews living in Jerusalem. Those in the outlying areas of Jerusalem traveled to the Temple during Passover, Shavuot, and Sukkot. God said "Three times a year shall all your men appear before the Lord your God....".  
4. Is the temple of Jerusalem synonymous with the local church? The term "Temple" refers to the ancient Temple in Jerusalem. Traditionally, until about 200 years ago, the Jewish house of worship was not called a temple, but a synagogue. The Jewish believers outside of Jerusalem would have attended synagogues. (Synagogues are consecrated spaces used for the purpose of prayer, Tanakh reading, study and assembly; however, a synagogue is not necessary for worship. Halakha holds that communal Jewish worship can be carried out wherever ten Jews assemble. Later, Jesus would say "wherever 2 or 3 are gathered.....") Synagogues would compare somewhat with our current day churches. A Temple would correlate with a place where the Spirit of God resides, i.e. the born-again believer. The New Testament doesn't mention purpose built church buildings, and in the New Testament era the most common meeting place for Christians was in each others' homes.
5. What is the meaning of "church"?  The church is the body of Christ and He is the head of the church (Ephesians 1:21-23). The church is "ekklesia" or "called out assembly".  Historically, it is not a physical building. The earliest church building devoted to Christian use is at Dura Europos in eastern Roman Syria. It was apparently a normal house converted for worship some time between 233 and 256. It was used when the believers in that area had become too many for homes.
6. Should we meet daily in homes and share our meals? Scripture describes the early church as meeting from house to house and breaking bread together. This historical fact is not a command to us, but written to describe the activities of the early church. However, scripture clearly says we should "not give up meeting together, as some are in the habit of doing, but encouraging one another--and all the more as you see the Day approaching." Hebrews 10:25. (see this for an explanation of Hebrews 10:25, about 1/2 down on the page. It does not mean what Scott uses it to mean.) Though no specific location is mentioned, "wherever two or three are gathered together, He is there." This would be in our homes, workplaces, local churches, outdoor areas, or any other place Christians may gather. We see the early church meeting in Aquila and Priscilla’s home in Ephesus (1Cor.16:19), in Philemon’s home (Phil.2), in Nympha’s home (Col.4:15) and in Lydia’s home (Acts 16:40). In fact, the early Christians worshipped without constructing special buildings for about 250 years.
7.  Are we the church when we meet in our homes? Yes. "For where two or three gather in my name, there am I with them." Matthew 18:20. Star Scott uses this verse to justify only a few meeting at Calvary Temple on a Friday night, but does not support two or three gathering in homes.  "...we can’t have our cliques, our little special 6 people."
8. Is Jesus in the "temple" (Calvary Temple building) or in the "church" (believers)? (Scott says "Jesus is worth coming up here to visit, amen? It's about Him, not the two or three.") Scripture says "Or do you not realize about yourselves that Jesus Christ is in you?” (2 Corinthians 13:5). "in whom you also are being built together into a dwelling of God in the Spirit." (Ephesians 2:22). Again, "For where two or three gather in my name, there am I with them." (Matthew 18:20). We do not need to go to a church building in order to "visit with Jesus." That statement is antithetical to the Word of God.
9. What is the difference between historical accounts in scripture and instructions to the church?  The Book of Acts is the history of the early church experiences. The Epistles, for example, contain detailed instruction for believers throughout all the church age. One is the permanent instruction and doctrine for the church. The other is a chronicle of the history of the early church experiences. To pull a verse from the Book of Acts, out of context, and use it to support a personal pet doctrine, is poor exegesis.

In addition to laying the groundwork for daily attendance, Scott wants you to know how selfish and self indulgent you are, disobedient, desiring your own ease and comfort, if you do not come to church daily:

"...one of the ways that we can do that, is to allow all of these selfish actions and the self indulgence and all of these things to be destroyed through our obedience to the word of God....I was glad when they said unto me... . Amen? Some of us frankly are just not glad anymore. it’s a drudgery, we are so busy doing our thing we are too tired to do God’s thing."

"We are so busy doing our thing we are too tired to do God’s thing".

Really? What "own things" are church members too tired from? If you are attending church nearly every day, where is all this extra time for "selfish" pursuits? Most men and many women work 5 days per week, both men and women have a home to care for. Many have children to care for. Is it selfish to have family dinner time? Is it selfish to spend the evening playing board games with your children? Maybe watching a movie and eating popcorn? Maybe spending an evening with friends? Spending time with your spouse? And not just once or twice a year when you have an anniversary or a birthday, but on a regular, frequent basis? Is it selfish to have prayer time at home on Tuesdays and Thursdays, praying for whomever God has placed on your hearts? Mothers, is it selfish to have your children in bed at 7:30 on a school night so they are well-rested? Is it self indulgent to teach our children to share the love of Jesus with the neighborhood children? (Parents, please read this)

Do not believe the lie that being at the church building with your family is the same as time with your family. Or the lie that caring and sowing into family, friends, (and even strangers) means spending your "free" time in a communal setting rather than in individual homes. And do not believe the lie that you don't have a choice.

Deut 11:19-20  "You shall teach them to your sons, talking of them when you sit in your house and when you walk along the road and when you lie down and when you rise up. You shall write them on the doorposts of your house and on your gates."

Deut 4:9  Only take care, and keep your soul diligently, lest you forget the things that your eyes have seen, and lest they depart from your heart all the days of your life. Make them known to your children and your children's children—

Proverbs 1:8-9  Hear, my son, your father's instruction, and forsake not your mother's teaching, for they are a graceful garland for your head and pendants for your neck.

 1 Corinthians 11:3  But I want you to understand that the head of every man is Christ, the head of a wife is her husband, and the head of Christ is God.  Star Scott is not the head of your family.

Please note: These are written to fathers, mothers, and children. Not to pastors, deacons, babysitters, Sunday School teachers, gym monitors, etc.

CONCLUSIONS:
  • The Temple in Jerusalem and the local church in Sterling are not synonymous.
  • Though the believers in Jerusalem met at the Temple courts for the purpose of preaching the gospel publicly, they also met in their homes for Christian teaching, prayer and fellowship.
  • If we are going to read Acts 2:45 as an instruction to the church, meaning that the local church must meet daily in a dedicated building, then it follows that Calvary Temple must sell all they have and divide among all believers in need. It also follows that they should be meeting in their homes daily, sharing their meals. 
  • The early church kept the festivals and feasts, does it follow that we should do the same? If Scott's reasoning is biblically sound, then we would have to keep the feasts also.
  • Those members of our community and our local churches who are without spouses, families, and relatives should be ministered to through other individuals and families. The encouragement from the pulpit should be for all to ask God to lead them to those in need. Inviting a lonely single into a home, whether a member of CT or not, for fellowship, food, care, discipleship, etc is far more beneficial than attending another "family fun night". Consider James 1:27 Pure religion and undefiled before God and the Father is this, To visit the fatherless and widows in their affliction...
  • Wherever 2 or 3 are gathered together, Jesus is in the midst of the gathering. Wherever it may be.
  • Calvary Temple members:  You have forsaken your God-given responsibility and right to be head of your own families, to hear from God concerning the direction of your family, and to minister to whomever God leads you to. You have allowed a man to take the place of God. 
  • Calvary Temple members: You have neglected your marriages, your children, your natural families outside of CT, your neighbors, and all those who God has put in your path. 
Star Scott says: "We are not to forsake the assembling together of ourselves, as the manner of some is, and even MORE, be more conscious, more aware. Don’t make the mistake of thinking you are the exception to this. A lot of times people don’t even go on to the next verse: for if we sin willfully after that we have received the knowledge of the truth, there remains no more sacrifice for our sins. So right in the middle of all of this redemption, revelation that there is no other name under heaven there is no other process by which men can be saved. He goes on and we see in chapter 6 and other places…..we tread the blood of Jesus under our feet counting it an unholy thing." (it is ironic that he accused people of not reading the following verse, and yet we have seen him do the very same thing with Acts 2:45)
  • Calvary Temple members:  You should be troubled by the fact that your pastor is accusing you of being selfish, self-indulgent, treading the blood of Jesus under your feet, and having no sacrifice for your sins because you choose to be home with your families, friends, relatives, or neighbors. Or because you choose to be led by God for the oversight of your life, family and homes.
None of this is to say we should not be meeting with one another, and even more as we see the day approaching.  (However, this scripture did not mean to have more and more meetings - it meant to be faithful to the meeting of the church on the first day of the week and even more faithful to the meeting as we see the day approaching) Of course we should! But we should not be coerced through twisting of scripture, fear of men's (Star Scott's) faces, fear of losing our salvation because we are not at church every time the doors open, and fear that we are self-indulgent because we stay home to minister to our families or friends.  And we should never follow one man's dictates to the exclusion of the leading of the Holy Spirit.

Why is this an important topic for discussion? If everyone is content to attend church daily, why should anyone care? We know it is a good thing for believers to gather together. However, Star Scott has systematically stripped Calvary Temple members the ability and blessing of hearing from God for themselves and their families. He has placed himself as the one to hear from God, and like Moses, come down from the mountain and speak to the people. And the people are expected to consider it the word of the Lord and obey Scott's directives. But God has something different for the believer in Jesus Christ. He expects us to seek God daily for His provision, to know the word of God for ourselves, and to be led by His Holy Spirit. The role of the 5 fold ministry is to equip the saints, not lord it over them.  

Romans 8:14  For all who are being led by the Spirit of God, these are sons of God.
Galatians 5:18  But if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under the Law.Galatians 5:25  If we live by the Spirit, let us also walk by the Spirit.

Friday, December 29, 2017

You Can't Have it Both Ways, Part 2



When I first attended Calvary Temple, my family and I came from another church. Not one time did anyone in CT leadership or among the congregation question my reasons for leaving another church to come to Calvary Temple. No one accused me of being "out of order" or "rebelling against designated authority."

NOT ONE Calvary Temple member "marked" me for leaving my previous church, an action they take routinely when someone leaves CT. And not one person from my old church accused me of rebellion, nor did they shun me. In fact, I am still friends with members of my old church.

But when I left Calvary Temple and began attending another church, I was rebuked for being out of order, rebelling against designated authority and was consequently "marked". (everyone who leaves Calvary Temple is marked, whether officially or unofficially. In practice, it's all the same.)

And now, let me ask the current members of Calvary Temple:

If you came from another church to attend CT, were YOU rebuked? were you told you were out of order? and a rebel to your previous "designated authority"? Were you told to go back to your pastor and ask permission to leave? Did your previous pastor label you a rebel?

Do you see a hypocritical disconnect here? Why is it fine to leave a church to attend Calvary Temple but not ok to leave Calvary Temple? Why does Star Scott say God placed you in Calvary, but he doesn't say God placed you in your previous church?
  • Tony and Lou, you left a bible believing church (was it Halpine?)  to attend CT, were you rebuked?
  • Tony and Jenny, why didn't you get sent back to your old church?
  • Carolyn, didn't you first attend a church in Round Hill?
  • Jon, why wasn't your dad sent back to the Presbyterian church in Md that he and his family attended? 
  • Kevin and Theresa, didn't you leave family members behind to attend CT?  Did Pastor Scott tell you to go back?
  • Tony and Linda, what church did you leave?
  • Candace, I think you attended a Calvary Chapel church in New York. Did a pastor accuse you of being a betrayer?
  • Gary and Becky, I seem to remember you were part of a church in Staunton. Did they label you a deserter? 
  • Connie, weren't you and Jeff in a church in Maryland?
  • Raymond and Rhonda, why did you leave your church? Why didn't Pastor Scott send you back?
  • Jon, Sarah, Joshua and Christina - why didn't Pastor Scott tell you and your parents to go back to NY?
  • Bea and family, were you rebuked for leaving your old church in Purcellville?
  • Steve, didn't you and your parents and siblings leave a baptist church in Sterling?   
This is just a sampling of the current members of Calvary that came from other churches. All of them would tell you they had a good reason for leaving their old church to come to Calvary Temple. 
  • Perhaps they took a job in this area
  • Maybe they moved here to be closer to family. 
  • Or heard Star Scott on the radio and thought it would be a good church to attend. 
  • Maybe they had gifts that they felt Calvary Temple was in need of.
  • Perhaps they felt called to minister in a new church.
  • Maybe it was for doctrinal reasons. 
  • Or they felt they were not being fed at their current church.
  • Maybe they came to CT because there were rumors of abuse in their old church and they didn't feel comfortable sitting under a pastor with  "history". 
  • Maybe their old church was under investigation by the state police, local police, FBI and IRS. 
Whatever the reason, it was enough to cause them to make a decision that no one questioned. Most likely not their old pastor and certainly not Star Scott. And yet leaving Calvary Temple is considered the worst kind of sin. Leaving CT earns you the label of rebel, daughter of satan, demon woman, unsaved, deserter, trouble maker, enemy, betrayer, defamer, backbiter, defiler, bitter, etc. 

The person leaving Calvary Temple is doing exactly what many current CT members did when they left their previous church. They chose to leave one church and attend another. 

Having attended CT for a number of years, I am going to anticipate Star Scott's response. One response might be something like this:

                We have always said if you attend Calvary Temple, you have the
                best chance of making it to heaven, and we are more concerned
                with your eternal state. Amen?

(and like Pavlov's dogs, the congregation will respond 'Amen!' and not give it another thought.)

Another response might be along the lines of disparaging those who have spoken out against Calvary Temple. After all, Scott is a champion of character assassination. So he might do some version of this:

                 Consider the source.

Note that neither of these will address the actual subject of this post.

So, the conclusion we must come to, according to Star Scott's "new doctrine",  is the majority of Calvary Temple members are in rebellion to their previous pastor, out of order, betrayers, dividers, enemies and deserters. If Star Scott is going to insist we are out of order for leaving CT, then he needs to rebuke and send many of his current members back to their original church. Or, if they are not these things, then neither are all of us who left Calvary Temple.

May I remind you - you can't have it both ways.


Galatians 5:18  But if you are led by the Spirit, you are not under the law.
Isaiah 30:21 And your ears shall hear a word behind you, saying, “This is the way, walk in it,” when you turn to the right or when you turn to the left.
Galatians 5:25 If we live by the Spirit, let us also walk by the Spirit.
Romans 8:1-2 There is therefore now no condemnation for those who are in Christ Jesus. For the law of the Spirit of life has set you free in Christ Jesus from the law of sin and death.
Acts 1:8 But you will receive power when the Holy Spirit has come upon you, and you will be my witnesses in Jerusalem and in all Judea and Samaria, and to the end of the earth.
Acts 20:22 And now, behold, I am going to Jerusalem, constrained by the Spirit, not knowing what will happen to me there.
Acts 5:29 We ought to obey God rather than men.



Thursday, December 14, 2017

The Enormity of it All

We were recently contacted by the writer of a blog that exposes abusive, authoritarian churches. The owner of this blog keeps an ongoing record of false teachers and asked for any additional information we wished to provide concerning Calvary Temple. As I began to compile a list of some of the problems associated with Calvary Temple, I was overwhelmed with the enormity of it all. It is one thing to hear of one or two problems in a church, but when one sees the list associated with Calvary Temple, it is shocking.
  • Star Scott teaches that he can hear from God on a level the average congregant cannot and is to be obeyed because he is the "man of God". To do otherwise is to be rebellious and out of order.
  • Counsel is to come from superiors in the ministry, i.e deacons and pastors. (not from friends or family members). 
  • Any infraction is to be immediately reported “up”. Matthew 18 principles only apply for minor infractions. 
  • When Star Scott's wife of 30+ years died, 2 1/2 weeks later he married a 20 yr old in the church. He stated that as High Priest, according to Old Testament instructions, he is not permitted to mourn and must marry a virgin that could be "molded". (thus conveniently eliminating any of the older women in the congregation).
  • Scott allows no oversight of the finances, has no set salary, buys whatever he wants and the church pays the bills. (since the IRS investigation, he says he now receives a salary. His lifestyle has only improved since then.) No questions asked. Though the congregants tithe and give offerings, they are not allowed a detailed account of where their money goes. 
  • Scott owns multiple race cars, motorcycles, expensive sports cars,  and classic cars. Has what he calls an "automotive outreach" in which he races and shows his Corvettes. 
  • Teaches mandatory 1st and 2nd tithe, and when necessary, a third tithe. If you drop off giving, you are excluded from church activities and benefits or asked to leave.
  • Teaches absolute shunning of anyone who "rebels" by leaving the church without his permission. (and he never gives permission, only puts out those who ask too many questions).
  • Advises spouses to divorce the spouse who has stopped attending the church.
  • Children must only marry within the church with leadership approval. No one may marry someone from outside of CT.
  • Scott and the other pastors as well as others close to leadership has covered up sexual abuse of several children and probably many more.
  • Allegedly sexually abused his two nieces when he was a youth pastor in CA. They were ages 9 and 11, went on 3 years. He fled CA (though it has been said by those who were in the church at the time that he was forced to leave) and came to Herndon VA to take over a small church. When the nieces came with parents to visit, he allegedly abused again. There is a police report on file with the Herndon, Virginia Police Department, though no charges were pressed.
  • Has claimed miracles that when questioned about the truthfulness, advised his staff to remove the “testimonies” from the website because there was “disagreement” about their veracity.
  • Calvary Temple/Star Scott have been investigated by the IRS, FBI, AFT, the Loudoun County Sheriff's Department and the Virginia State Police.
  • ROUTINELY badmouths - slanders -  past members and other churches as well as other pastors in the area.
  • Multiple families have been divided, parents have not seen their children for upwards of 25 years and children are cut off from their parents. If a child no longer wants to attend CT, Star Scott advises parents to put "rebellious or backslidden" children out on the street with only the clothes they are wearing. One 14 year old girl showed up at an ex-Calvary member home because she had nowhere to go.
  • Insists that if a child was raised in Calvary Temple, "they have no choice" but to be a Calvary Temple believer. As soon as a child questions anything, the child is called into multiple meetings and "counseled." 
  • Everyone at CT knows to keep their questions to themselves, even in their own households. One woman we know was terrified to question any of the problems she was seeing for fear her husband would put her out. 
  • There is a culture of fear within CT, members know what the stakes are if they disagree. They will lose their family and reputation.
  • Star Scott takes multiple vacations a year, all first class, while some members of the church cannot buy a new car.
  • Scott owns multiple properties of which most of the congregation is unaware.  
  • Star Scott ridicules people spending $5.00 on a Starbucks coffee while his wife shops on Rodeo Drive and sports a $25,000+ engagement ring. 
  • Teaches that fathers are to carry out the vision of the PASTOR, rather than raise up children in the nurture and admonition of the LORD. Fathers are not to have a vision for their own families.
  • God-given families are secondary to the "church family".
  • Forced a wife and mother to live 91 days in a hotel so she could be "broken". Not allowed to see her children. 
  • Finances and family problems are openly discussed in deacon's meetings without member's knowledge or consent.
  • Abuses (sexual, physical and emotional) are covered up by the leadership. Members are taught to leave it to leadership to handle. Though there are known cases of sexual abuse; they were never reported to the police. 
  • The pastor tells congregants to read only what he recommends. (mostly his own books, see CT website). An associate pastor told the church to use their own personal study for the reinforcement of what the pastor is teaching, not what they believe God is telling them.
  • Children, during youth group meetings, have heard very intimate details of Star Scott's sex life from Scott himself.
  • Women, upon the loss of a child may not ask God "Why?". To do so would be rebellious and not honoring to God.
  • Slander; destroying reputations of anyone who disagrees with Star Scott.
  • Star Scott lied about his educational background.
  • Star Scott uses the pulpit to gossip about and bully the members. It is not necessary for him to name names, as everyone in the church knows exactly who he is talking about. Everyone's personal business is in danger of being broadcasted to the entire church. People learn to keep their mouths shut. (or to ask only questions that make themselves look good.)
  • Scott uses ridicule, mockery, disdain, criticism, contempt, exaggeration etc in his "teachings". Members are careful to stay under the radar to avoid such treatment.
  • Members are convinced they will spiritually suffer if they leave the church to attend another.
  • If you attend Calvary Temple, "you have been placed here by God" and are told that you have no right to leave.
Many Calvary Temple members might be aware of much of the above, but perhaps not every point. The newcomer to CT only sees the seemingly positive aspects of belonging to a group of Christians that appear to be committed to one another. But as time goes by, members begin to see the ugly underbelly of CT. New members, and even many long time members, are kept from "reading the fine print". By the time all becomes clear, they are trapped through marriage, family, and fear. Many lack financial resources should they decide to leave Calvary Temple. In addition, most have given up close relationships with friends and family members that do not attend CT. Leaving Calvary Temple can be extremely difficult.

Make no mistake, Calvary Temple is NOT a good place. It has the potential (and likelihood) to destroy your life, marriage, family and faith. Stay far away from Calvary Temple of Sterling, Virginia. 

Wednesday, September 6, 2017

Lies From Calvary Temple

Fresno State or Fresno City College???

This post is primarily directed to current Calvary Temple members. Your pastor has repeatedly lied to you.

As a past member of Calvary Temple, I sat in many services when Star Scott proudly referred to his time at Fresno State. (Below are some quotations from the Calvary Temple website to support my statement). Fresno State is the common name, used on the university's website, for California State University, Fresno. Fresno State is the prestigious university that alumni are proud to call their alma mater. Few however, if any, would brag about their years at FRESNO CITY COLLEGE. Star Scott, though he said he attended Fresno State, did not. He attended a community college. 

Furthermore, did he really have a football scholarship - the "free ride" he often referred to? If he did have a scholarship, it was TO A COMMUNITY COLLEGE.

Here is the bio presumably written by Mr Scott himself: (red emphasis mine)


Pastor Star R. Scott

Senior Pastor at Calvary Temple Church
United States
Religious Institutions

CurrentSenior Pastor at Calvary Temple Church
EducationBerean Bible College & Seminary, Fresno City College, Bethany Bible College
Summary
Pastor Star R. Scott is Senior Pastor of Calvary Temple in Sterling, Virginia, where he has ministered since 1973. Pastor Scott spent...


The following are quotations from Mr Scott
  • "Fresno State was paying for everything else........" Living in the Supernatural Pt 5 11/24/02
  • "And I was playing football at Fresno State-and I'm good-looking." Two Become One Pt 1 7/5/06
  • "I can still remember pulling up alongside the road there at Fresno State and walking across this one big practice field "  Preferring His Presence Pt 3 6/25/00
  • "and was attending Fresno State...."Faith that Prevails Pt 9 7/8/12
  • "My brother and I went to Fresno State to the football game.....and this guy is sitting there and I asked, 'So are you alumni here?' "Oh yeah; we're alumni." So I said, "Well, I am too."  Faith that Prevails Pt 11 7/11/12
  • "I looked into the newspaper and the University of Nevada was playing Fresno State. He went to Nevada and I went to Fresno."  The Cross Pt 2  2/6/05
  • "I was at California State University, Fresno." Sure Foundation Pt.4 8/13/09
Calvary Temple members, does this concern you? Your pastor deliberately deceived you into thinking he had attended Fresno State. He actually told outright lies, not just once, but many times.

What true man of God would lie to and deceive his "followers"?



Wednesday, August 30, 2017

He Said That? Part 4

The following statements were recently made by Star Scott during a teaching he calls The God of This World.  Mr Scott has a rebuke for all who dare to ask God the question "why?".

"Job loses everything he has. Can you imagine in one day all your kids were gone? Tragic death and they are all gone. Sadly, your wife is still there. There is no greater burden in life than an unregernerated [sic] wife. Could God have stopped Satan from killing Job's kids? Absolutely! Why,Why, Why, Why? You are not allowed to ask why. All your kids die, you are not allowed to ask why. .....here's what you are able to do. The Lord gives and the Lord takes away, blessed be the name of the Lord. Hallelujah, amen? If you are not there, you are worldly. If you are not there, you are being affected and your life is being directed by Satan's tragedies and attacks and God is not being glorified because it's all about you. 'Poor me. Look how I have been abused. I have my rights, this isn't fair....'".

When I heard this, I felt deep sadness and anger on behalf of mothers and fathers who have gone through the unspeakable grief of losing a child.  I imagine it is a testing of one's faith and trust in God like none other.

But Star Scott has a message for you: "You are not allowed to ask why". If you ask why, you are worldly. If you question God, you are being led by Satan. If you ask why, you are not glorifying God. If you ask why, you are a whiny crybaby saying "poor me". If you cry out to God with questions, you are accusing God of abuse.

Mr Scott focuses on Job's wife and the statement she makes to Job, "curse God and die". His conclusion is that Job's wife is the worst possible burden for Job to have to endure (I guess even worse than losing all his children, wealth, etc.) and because of her momentary outburst, she is lost for all eternity.

Yes, Job's wife speaks to her husband "Curse God and die!" But Job's response to his wife is not as condemning as Star Scott's is. "...[Job] said to her, "You speak like one of the foolish women speaks. Shall we indeed accept good from God and not accept adversity?" Note that Job says ...."like one of the foolish women"...... He does not call her a foolish woman, only that she is speaking like one. He then goes on to comfort her with his own hard-won wisdom.... "Shall we indeed accept good from God and not accept adversity?" And yet even after Job says this, he struggles with what the will of God has brought into his life.

(If you are interested enough to pursue this subject, it is enlightening to do a study on the word barak, translated in Job to mean curse. The Hebrew verb barak occurs just over 325 times in the Old Testament, and is often translated to mean bless, or to kneel down. Perhaps Job's wife was actually saying 'you have kept your integrity, now kneel down, bless God, and die. Indeed, some scholars believe this is the more accurate translation.)

And that is all we know of Job's wife. There is no mention of Job putting his wife out, or of God condemning her to hell, or of her death. There is also no mention of Job marrying another woman. At the close of the book of Job, we find that the Lord restored his fortunes and gave him twice as much as he had before. We can assume (and many scholars do) that Job's wife bore him his children and shared in his blessings.

Star Scott states that  Job "... kept his integrity, didn’t he. He makes great statements like the Lord gives and the Lord takes away. Blessed be the name of the lord." 

But Job also spoke the following:

"Why then did you bring me out of the womb? I wish I had died before any eye saw me." Job 10:18

"Like a slave who longs for the shadow, and like a hireling who looks for his wages, so I am allotted months of emptiness, and nights of misery are apportioned to me." Job 7:2.3

"I would speak to the Almighty, and I desire to argue my case with God." Job 13:3


“What strength do I have, that I should hope?” (Job 6:11 NKJV)

Does it please you [God] to oppress me, to spurn the work of your hands,
while you smile on the schemes of the wicked?” Job 10:3


“He [God] throws me into the mud, and I am reduced to dust and ashes. I cry out to you, O God, but you do not answer; I stand up, but you merely look at me.” Job 30:19

I loathe my very life; therefore I will give free rein to my complaint and speak out in the bitterness of my soul. Job 10:1

“As surely as God lives, who has denied me justice,
the Almighty, who has made me taste bitterness of soul…” Job 27:2

“…then know that God has wronged me and drawn his net around me. Though I cry, ‘I’ve been wronged!’ I get no response; though I call for help, there is no justice.”  Job 19:6,7

And others have spoken boldly to God, asking why? when? how long? Even accusing God of forsaking them.

From the Book of Psalms: 

“Why, O LORD, do you stand far away? Why do you hide yourself in times of trouble?” (10:1)

“Why have you forgotten me?” (42:9b)

“Why do you forget our affliction and oppression?” (44:24b)

LORD, how long shall the wicked, how long shall the wicked triumph? (94:3)

My God, my God, why have you forsaken me? why are you so far from saving me? (22:1)

From Jeremiah  Why was I born? Was it only to have trouble and sorrow, to end my life in disgrace? (20:18)

From Habakkuk  O Lord, how long shall I cry for help and you will not hear? Or cry to you Violence! and you will not save? (1:2)

And finally from Mark   Jesus said "My God, My God, why have You forsaken Me?" 15:34b

And yet according to Star Scott, the woman who loses her child/children may not ask God why. The worst tragedy a mother can endure and Mr Scott calls her worldly if she asks God why.

But God in His infinite love, grace and mercy speaks to us:

If any of you lacks wisdom, you should ask God, who gives generously to all without finding fault, and it will be given to you.  James 1:5

For everyone who asks receives; he who seeks finds; and to him who knocks, the door will be opened.…Matthew 7:8

I sought the LORD, and He answered me, And delivered me from all my fears.  Psalm 34:4  

Sadly, Mr Scott, in his attempt to silence women, has twisted the scripture to say far more than it does. Though he often says "ladies, I'm on your side...", he more often speaks against them. (May I remind you of the time he taught on women's role in the home - he asked Greer what she thought the women were hearing. Her response? That women are evil. Even his own wife understood Scott's opinion of women.) 

Because God is largely silent concerning Job's wife, why is Star Scott building a principle from the one emotional response of a grieving mother? Not only is there no scriptural basis for this new "principle", Mr Scott is doing exactly what scripture warns against:

Do not add to His words or He will reprove you, and you will be proved a liar. Proverbs 30:6


Why does Mr Scott teach his congregation that God is not big enough to handle their questions and doubts? Doesn't God already know our hearts? In a loving, honest relationship, we are free to come to God as our Father, knowing He will never turn us away. He is always willing to hear and comfort us in our times of grief and doubt.